When I decided to write something up for Women In Horror Month, a bunch of names ran through my head. Amy Steel, Barbara Crampton, Kelly Jo Minter but I decided to go with Katharine Isabelle. The main reason being is I was on IMDB a while back and someone had started a “Favorite Scream Queen” thread. So, I went in and said Katharine Isabelle. Within 10 minutes, I had a reply from someone who had previously said Scout Taylor Compton, Katie Cassidy and Mary Elizabeth Winstead. ” I don’t think she’s been in enough horror to be a Scream Queen.” I was in shock.

She started doing horror themed projects as a teen with roles in The X-Files, Goosebumps and Disturbing Behavior but it wasn’t until 2000 that she really made her first mark in the genre.

Ginger Snaps was a little Canadian werewolf movie that surprised critics and most horror fans. It was a clever take on the genre and Katharine received great reviews as Ginger. Playing a rebellious teen who is stuck in suburban hell who is then attacked by a werewolf on the eve of her first period, Katharine is electric. As she further evolves into the wolf, you see all humanity slip away from her but even at her worst, she’s still a fascinating character. Both Katharine, Emily Perkins (who plays her sister Bridgette) and Mimi Rogers (who plays their clueless mom) make this movie a darkly comedic horror gem.

Post Ginger Snaps, she did roles in Bones, Insomnia and the 2002 TV remake of Carrie but it wasn’t until 2003’s Freddy VS Jason that she made another mark in the genre. Originally auditioning for the lead Lori, Katharine ended up playing party girl Gibb. In what could have been a throwaway role, she ends up out-acting most of the leads and is one of the few characters I had sympathy for. She also serves as the catalyst to which Freddy and Jason start their battles. As she’s about to be killed in her dream by Freddy, Jason impales her sleeping corpse.

After FvJ, she dabbled a lot in tv shows (having a memorable guest stint on season 2 of Supernatural and a homage to Freddy in an episode of Smallville) and direct to DVD horror (Hard Ride To Hell, 30 Days of Night 2, 13 Eerie). Some entertaining and some not so much. I will say no matter how bad the movie may have ended up, she always gives 100% in her role.

Then came 2012’s American Mary, Playing the tragic anti-hero Mary Mason, once again you witness a character’s descent into dark places. This time though, it’s not a werewolf that causes it but a traumatic incident at a party throw by her teacher. She not only gets her revenge but finds she has a knack for “alternate” surgeries. It’s another memorable character in the horror genre for Katharine Isabelle.

Now, she just wrapped See No Evil 2 and is finishing up a run on Syfy’s successful Being Human before headed to the amazingly dark and twisted Hannibal. A tragically under-watched series that trumps The Following in almost every way.

So, why is she so underrated?

I feel a lot of it has to do with the fact that she’s prefers to stay in Canada. She’s not an LA girl nor does she turn up in a bunch of horror remakes. She works when she wants to. She’s not a big “scene” queen nor does she promote herself endlessly on social media. But she has a loyal fan-base, myself included, that will hopefully keep growing.

–Andrew Beirl

One of my favorite women in horror is not from an 80’s film, but one that just happens to be set during that time. I’m talking about Jocelin Donahue, who played Samantha in Ti West’s House of the Devil. Samantha is a character that seems very genuine and really makes you root for her in the film. The character is struggling with money problems, as many of us can relate to. There are several red flags about the babysitting job that would ordinarily make most people decide against it, but Samantha’s desperation to improve her living situation makes her decision to take the job much more believable (to her best friend’s dismay).

The majority of the film’s scenes feature Samantha alone in the house. You can feel her curiosity as she explores the rooms, and also her ever rising uneasiness as she begins to realize that something isn’t quite right. Donahue plays the character well, and is able to carry the movie on her shoulders without losing the audience. By the end, you really get invested with her character, which makes the climax even more intense. You want Samantha to overcome the evil forces out to get her and just hope she makes it out alive. The House of the Devil is one of my favorite horror movies, and a good part of that is because of Jocelin Donahue’s performance.

-Miles Wilson

Throughout the years of horror, we have grown familiar with names such as Sally, Laurie, Alice, Ginny, and Nancy. These final girls from early slasher history left such a huge impression in the horror community that they are familiar by just first name basis. For a while it almost seemed that we’d never get another Final or Lead Girl to live up to these standards or become that legendary. That is until 1996 when a certain Wes Craven film opened in cinemas and soon became the most successful slasher film in horror to this day. Yes, ladies and gentlemen, I am referring to none other than Sidney Prescott, brilliantly played by Neve Campbell.

When we first meet Sidney in the original film, she is scarred after the brutal death of her mother one year prior. It is only when she and friends become the targets of a maniacal serial killer that she must stand up to the plate. When Sidney is first attacked by the killer, she immediately fights back and uses her smarts to try and escape, which she does. By the end, even when she is revealed to gut-punching truth about who the killer is and who is actually responsible for her mother’s death, she always manages to stay strong, and ultimately take down BOTH of the killers who have been tormenting her and reap her of her once happy family.

Randy: “Careful, this is the moment when the supposedly dead killer comes back to life…for one last scare.”
Sidney: *after shooting Billy in the head*: “Not in my movie.”

In Scream 2 we find Sidney at college, hoping to start anew, she has a close group of friends and a loving boyfriend with “no apparent psychotic tendencies.” It isn’t too long before Sid experiences déjà vu when murders start taking place, and once again Sidney and her friends become the initial targets. It is at this point Sid is conflicted her where her trust lies and is wondering if history will repeat itself. Despite all of this, she continues to still keep her strength as well as her guard up. This time she is not afraid of running, she willing to confront her “ghost” head on, from talking back to the killer during their calls, having the perfect chance to run, but chooses to see who the monster under the mask is, and once again giving one hell of a showdown when confronted by the killers. She doesn’t break once.

Sidney: “You’re forgetting one thing about Billy Loomis…I fucking killed him!”

In Scream 3 we find Sidney now in seclusion, she’s not so much afraid of the world, but more so she is extremely careful and alert. Her home is fully secured and locked, she goes by a new name, and works from home. But yet again, the killer finds her and Sidney knows that her friends are in danger. Without even a second thought, she flies to Hollywood to help Dewey and Gale solve the murders and bring this new killer down. But this time it’s different. This killer is a real ghost from the past, and this means Sidney must confront all of her demons in order to fully rise to victory and bring the killer down. When it’s revealed the killer is Sidney’s long lost brother that her mother abandoned, and he is the reason why all of the horror in Sidney’s life happened, it becomes and all-out brawl. Sidney is at her most fierce and most cunning, all the way to the killer’s death, and she feels she can live at ease.

Sidney: “It’s your turn to scream asshole!”

It is ten years after the original Woodsboro murders, and Sidney is now able to
return home to promote her book entitled “Out of Darkness” about her journey through the turmoil she went through. But with Sidney’s return, so do the murders. Someone is trying to remake the events of the events ten years ago. But now, Sidney finds her younger cousin Jill, her aunt, and Jill’s friends added to the list of targets. With a new decade, come the new rules, and Sid must put together the pieces as the bodies pile up. After all she has been through, Sidney is now no longer afraid. She does whatever she can to protect those around her, including racing to Jill’s friend’s house to protect her from her doom, throws herself in harm’s path to save Jill, as well as others. By the final showdown, Sidney shows that even when the enemy is family, she refuses to be weak, she stands her ground, fearless, stealth, and out of darkness.

Sidney: “You forgot the first rule of remakes Jill. Don’t fuck with the original.”

Throughout those ten years, Sidney has never once faltered in her actions. She always used her smarts, always stayed strong, and always confronted her internal and external conflicts head on. She also showed that she was always willing to put her life ahead of others to save them. In the moments where the average person would feel at a loss, Sidney kept on going. But what makes her the most special and unique is that she’s the one recurring Final/Lead Girl in a slasher series to never be killed off. To me, that makes her the ultimate Final Girl in slasher history.

–Cody Landman